By Tim Slavin
June 4th 2008
HTML email newsletters have come a long way in the five years since this article was first published. HTML email is still a very successful communications medium for both publishers and readers. Publishers can track rates for email opens, forwards, and clickthroughs, and thereby can measure reader interest in products and topics; readers are presented with information that’s laid out like a web page, in a way that’s more visually appealing, and much easier to scan and navigate, than plain text email.
HTML Email Fundamentals
The biggest pain when coding HTML email is that so many different software tools are available for reading email, from desktop software such as Eudora, Outlook, AOL, Thunderbird, and Lotus Notes, to web-based email services such as Yahoo!, Hotmail, and Google Mail. If you thought it was difficult to ensure the cross-browser compatibility of your web sites, be aware that this is a whole new game — each of these email software tools can display the same email in vastly different ways. And even when these tools do display an HTML email properly, accounting for variances in, for example, the widths at which readers size their windows when reading emails makes things even trickier.
Whether you choose to code your HTML email by hand (my personal preference) or to use an existing template, there are two fundamental concepts to keep in mind when creating HTML email:
- Use HTML tables to control the design layout and some presentation. You may be used to using pure CSS layouts for your web pages, but that approach just won’t hold up in an email environment.
- Use inline CSS to control other presentation elements within your email, such as background colors and fonts.
The quickest and easiest way to see how HTML tables and inline CSS interact within an HTML email is to download some templates from Campaign Monitor and MailChimp. When you open up one of these templates, you’ll notice a few things that we’ll discuss in more detail later:
- CSS style declarations appear below the
bodytag, not between the
- No CSS shorthand is used: instead of using the abbreviated style rule
font: 12px/16px Arial, Helvetica, you should instead break this shorthand into its individual properties:
divs are used sparingly to achieve specific effects, while HTML tables do the bulk of the layout work.
- CSS style declarations are very basic, and do not make use of any CSS.
Step 1: Use HTML Tables for Layout
That’s right: tables are back, big time! Web standards may have become the norm for coding pages for display in web browsers, but this isn’t the Web, baby. Mail clients are light years behind the eight-ball in terms of CSS support, which means that we must resort to using tables for layout if we really want our newsletters to display consistently for every reader (see the reading list at the end of this article for some excellent resources on CSS support in mail clients).
So put your standards-compliant best practices and lean markup skills aside: we’re about to get our hands dirty!
The first step in creating an HTML email is to decide what kind of layout you want to use. For newsletters, single column and two-column layouts work best, because they control the natural chaos that results when a large amount of content is pushed into such a small space as an email.
A single-column layout typically consists of:
- a header, containing a logo and some (or all) of the navigation links from the parent web site to reinforce the branding and provide familiarity for site visitors
- intra-email links to stories that appear further down in the email
- a footer at the bottom of the email, which often contains links that are identical to the top navigation, as well as instructions for unsubscribing
Two-column emails also use a header and footer. Like a two-column web page, they typically use a narrow, side column to house features and links to more information, while the wider column holds the body content of the email.
Promotional emails follow similar rules but contain much less in the way of content and links. They often include one or two messages, and sometimes make use of one big image with small explanatory text and some links below the image.
All of these email layout possibilities can be created easily, using HTML tables to divide up the space into rows and columns. In fact, using HTML tables is the only way to achieve a layout that will render consistently across different mail clients.
No matter how your email is designed, it’s important to remember that the most important content should appear at or near the top of the email, so it is visible immediately when a reader opens your email. The top left of an email message is often the first place people look when they open an email.
This is the approach that I use to create HTML emails:
- For a two-column layout, create one table each for the header, the two center content columns, and the footer — that’s three tables in all. Wrap these tables into another container table. Use the same approach for single-column layouts, but give the content table one column. This approach is especially suitable if the design of your email contains images that are broken up over multiple table cells. Otherwise, a single table with
tdrows for its header (with
colspan="2"if the design uses two columns), content, and footer should display fine in all but Lotus Notes email software.
- Use the attributes within the table and
tdtags to control the table’s display. For example, setting
center, if that suits the design),
cellspacing="0", and so on. This primarily helps older email clients to display the email in a (barely) acceptable way.
- Even if the design of your email doesn’t include a border around your table, you might find it helpful during development to set
border="1"to help with the debugging of any problems that arise with the internal alignment of
tdtags. Change it back to
border="0"for testing and production.
While this approach might offend purists who prefer to code using the latest standards, it is the only approach that’s viable at this point. But the fact that we’re using tables for layout doesn’t mean we need to resort to old-school methods entirely. For example, no matter how poorly Lotus Notes displays HTML email, you should never have to resort to using the
font tag. And while Outlook 2007’s HTML rendering engine is less than perfect, it does display basic HTML tables just fine.
There are some caveats, though; let’s take a look at styling our text next.
Step 2: Add CSS Styles
Did I say CSS support was poor in mail clients? Well, it is. But you can (and should) still utilize CSS for the styles in your email once your nested table layout is in place. There are just a few things to watch out for. Here are the steps that I use.
First, use inline styles to store all of your style information, as shown here:
<p style="color: red;">
Do not use the CSS
style declaration in the HTML
head tag, as you might when authoring web pages. Instead, place your
style declaration right below the
body tag — Google Mail, in particular, looks for any style in the email and (helpfully) deletes it. Also, don’t bother using the
link element to reference an external style sheet: Google Mail, Hotmail, and other email software will ignore, modify, or delete these external references to a style sheet.
For your container table — the one that houses the header, content, and footer tables — set the table width to 98%. It turns out that Yahoo! mail needs that 1% cushion on either side in order to display the email properly. If side gutters are critical to your email’s design, set the width to 95% or even 90% to avoid potential problems. Of course, the tables inside the container table should be set to 100%.
Put general font style information in the table
td, closest to the content. Yes, this can result in repetitive style declarations within multiple
td cells. Put font style definitions into heading (e.g.
a tags only when necessary.
divs sparingly to float small boxes of content and links to the right or left inside a table’s
td cell. Google Mail, for one, seems to ignore the CSS float declaration (yet Yahoo! and Hotmail cope with it just fine). Sometimes it’s better to code a more complex table layout than to rely on the float declaration. Or, since it’s all too easy to clutter up an email, ask your designer to put the floated content in the narrow side column instead. Flaky support for floats is one issue that may cause an email design to be reworked.
divs appear to be barely useful,
spans appear to work almost every time, because they’re inline elements. In some cases,
spans can be used for more than just coloring or sizing text: they can be used to position text above or below content.
Note that some email delivery services will unpack style definitions to make them more explicit and, therefore, more readable by all email software. For example, the CSS shorthand
style="margin: 10px 5px 10px 0;" may be expanded into the long style declaration shown earlier. Test each email and look to see what happens to the email code. Start with CSS shorthand because, in the worst case, it appears to work well with all email software.
If you’ve downloaded and studied the email templates from Campaign Monitor and MailChimp, you’ll see that they treat the container table as if it were the
body tag. The Campaign Monitor team refer to this table as the “BodyImposter,” which is a great way to think about the frame or wrapper table. From a CSS perspective, the container table does what the
body element would do if services like Google Mail didn’t disable or ignore the
Step 3: Adopt Best Practices
Knowing that you’ve created valid HTML email using the guidelines I’ve suggested is only part of the solution — there are several best practices that you should follow to ensure that your email is well received.
The next step is to test your HTML email in a variety of email clients. Often this will identify problems that require workarounds.
The first test tools to use are the Firefox and Internet Explorer web browsers. If the email displays well or perfectly in both browsers, there’s a good chance that testing the email in Outlook, Yahoo!, Google Mail, and other services will reveal only minor problems. I’d also recommend testing your email in Internet Explorer 6 — this should give you a good indication of how your email will render in Outlook 2003 (refer to the list of resources at the end of this article for information on running Internet Explorer 6).
Once the email appears fine in those two web browsers, use an email delivery service to send the email to a range of test email accounts. Ideally, this should include accounts with the Yahoo!, Hotmail, and Google Mail services.
The test accounts you use should, of course, be determined by the domain names in the mailing list of people who will receive the email. For example, if there are no AOL subscribers on this list, it’s probably a waste of time and money to set up, and test with, an AOL email account.
Here are the most common code tweaks that I’ve found necessary during this test phase:
- Sometimes, a switch from percentage widths to fixed widths is needed. While this is not ideal — because readers can and do resize their email windows while reading — sometimes, using a fixed width is the only way to have a layout to display properly in multiple email clients.
- If there’s a spacing issue with the columns in the email design, first tweak the
cellspacingattributes of the HTML tables. If that doesn’t work, apply CSS
paddingattributes. HTML spacing works better with older email software.
- Image displacement can occur when a
tdcell is closed right below an
imgtag. This is an ancient HTML problem. Putting the
</td>tag right after (on the same line as) the
imgtag eliminates the annoying and mystifying 1-pixel gap.
In addition, the following best practices are recommended:
- If an image is sliced up and spread across several HTML table cells, test the email using many test accounts. Sometimes, it might look great in Outlook but be shifted by one or more pixels in Hotmail and other services. Also consider making the image a background image on a new HTML table that encases all of the table rows and columns that would display parts of your background image; this often achieves the same effect as slicing an image up, but uses less code and can provide better results (see below). Note that Outlook 2007 does not display background images; be sure to test your email code with your target email software.
- For background images, use the table’s
backgroundattribute instead of using CSS. This works more consistently across email software than other potential solutions.
- Store the email images on a web server — preferably in a folder that’s separate from your web site’s images (for example, in a folder called
/images/email), and don’t delete them. Some people open emails weeks or months later, the same way people use bookmarks to return to web sites.
- Be sure all your images use the
widthattributes. Setting values for these attributes improves results in Google Mail, as well as maintaining your layout when a reader has their images turned off. Note, however, that Outlook 2007 does not recognize the
- Use the
target="_blank"attribute for the a tags, so that people who read with webmail services don’t have the requested page appear within their webmail interface.
- While a 1×1-pixel image can be used to force spacing to create a precise email layout, spammers often use 1×1-pixel images to determine if their email has been opened. As such, using this practice will increase the likelihood that your email is classified as spam.
- Similarly, avoid using a large image “above the fold” in the email. This is another classic spammer practice and may cause your email to be interpreted as spam.
It’s important to make sure your HTML email displays acceptably with images turned off. Thunderbird, Outlook and many other email applications set the display of images to “off” by default. For example, if you use a background image to provide a background color with white font color over it, make sure the default background color for that part of the HTML table is dark, not white.
When I’m testing how an email displays with images off, I usually use my text editor to replace each image’s
src attribute with a unique combination of characters such as “xsrcx”, and then revert it back again after the test.
As part of testing an email, also include a test for potential “spamminess”. SpamCheck is a useful service that highlights issues that might cause an email to trigger spam filters. While it comes bundled as a tool called Site Build It, that is available for purchase, the online version of SpamCheck is a free service, and no purchase is necessary to make use of it.
Once the HTML email has been tweaked so that it displays well in your test email accounts, the next step is to go through a checklist. For example, verify the following:
- Does the From address display properly (as a name, not a bare email address)?
- Is the subject line correct?
- Is the contact information correct and visually obvious?
- Does the top of the email display the text, “You received this email because … Unsubscribe instructions are at the bottom of this email.”?
- Does your email contain text asking readers to add your From address to their email address book?
- Does the top of your email include a link to the web version of the message?
Code for GoogleMail, LotusNotes & Outlook 2007
Google Mail, Lotus Notes, and Outlook 2007 present their own unique coding challenges. Outlook 2007, believe it or not, has significantly less support for CSS than previous versions of Outlook!
Google Mail’s lack of support is a little more forgiveable — because the application runs in a browser, it cannot control the contents of the emails it displays. Consequently, Google’s engineers have had to take steps to ensure that their application displays properly regardless of the quality of the HTML or CSS in which emails are written.
As a result, Google Mail is a new web mail service that acts like an artifact of the early 1990s, when web standards were primitive. It takes some work, but it is possible to crack open a Google Mail page and see just how convoluted the services approach to rendering HTML email actually is.
For one thing, Google Mail deletes the CSS styles contained between any style tags, no matter where they appear in the email. And fonts displayed within HTML tables — the only alternative to using styles — have the odd habit of appearing larger than intended, no matter how the HTML email is structured.
The good news, however, is that if you code to account for the oddities of these email three applications, your HTML email code is more likely to display well in most, if not all, email clients. Here are some techniques that appear to work well in Google Mail and other older email software:
- Define the background color in a
tdcell with the
bgcolorattribute, not the CSS style.
- As noted above, use the
backgroundattribute in the
tdcell for background images instead of using CSS. One side-effect of this approach is that the background image can be made as tall as needed — if the content used in your email template is likely to vary in size, using an extra-tall background image in this way allows the height of the email shrink or expand, depending on the height of the copy, from one email to the next. Remember, though, that Outlook 2007 ignores background images completely.
- If it works better, use the padding declaration to control margins within a td cell. The margin style does not work in these cells, but padding does.
- If you need a border around a
tdcell, keep in mind that Google Mail displays a border around a
tdcell when it’s defined in a
div, but not when it’s defined as a border style in a
- If you need a light-colored link against a dark background color, put the font definition in the
tdcell (so it applies to
atags equally) then add a
color:style to the a tag.
- If the
afonts appear to be different sizes, wrap the
atag in a
- Google Mail aggressively uses the right-hand column of the Google Mail user interface, which squeezes the HTML email into the center panel. Be sure the padding style in the content tds is set to 10 pixels all round, so that text does not hit against the left and right edges.
- When testing an HTML email with a Google Mail account, it’s likely that you’ll find that one or more font styles are missing in the
a, and other tags. Inspect every font carefully to make sure Google Mail displays the fonts correctly.
Besides Google Mail, there’s another, less obvious hazard a programmer faces when creating HTML email: Lotus Notes. Many large corporations continue to support and upgrade their Notes installations (as of 2004, IBM reported that 95 million people used Notes).
Unfortunately, it’s impossible to tell which companies use Notes. The best approach is to follow the guidelines described in this article — the more primitive the code, the more likely it will work well, if not perfectly, with Notes.
That said, it’s quite possible that Notes will introduce to your HTML email quirks that are almost beyond belief. For example, the software can convert images to their proprietary formats, or simply ignore flawless basic HTML in one email, but display other HTML fine in another email.
A trial version of Lotus Notes is available for download if you need to test your mail in Notes — see the resource list at the end of the article. Here are a few tips that will help you convince Notes to display your HTML email properly:
- As we discussed previously, use a container table that contains all the internal layout tables (for example, for the header, content, and footer). This keeps the email together in one chunk of HTML, so pieces of the layout are less likely to wander when displayed in Notes.
- Create a gutter around the container table by setting the width to a percentage and/or using a cellpadding of at least 5.
- As I mentioned earlier, avoid using a
styledeclaration in your email’s
headtag. It might be the approach that adheres to web standards, but Notes (like Google Mail) might delete your styles. Rely, instead, on inline styles within the
a, and other tags.
- Use absolute URLs to images stored on a web server. You can’t do much about Notes converting images, but using remote images might help.
- Intra-email links, using named anchors, rarely (if ever) work in Notes. It’s simply best to avoid links that jump down the email to a specific piece of content.
colspans in your HTML tables. Notes — especially its earlier versions — can deal only with basic table layouts.
- Be sure that your
tdcell widths are accurate. Unlike web browsers, which automatically set all cells to the widest-defined width, Notes sizes each
tdcell based on its defined width.
- Centering an email layout usually won’t work in Notes. Email layouts generally have to be left-aligned.
Using these techniques to achieve a successful render in Google Mail and Lotus Notes will ensure that your emails also display fine in Outlook 2007, which uses an older HTML rendering engine. Microsoft has published details about what their email software will and won’t display properly; more details can be found in the Resources section at the end of this article).
The Email Standards Project has additional details on CSS support in Outlook 2007, and Microsoft is one of the companies at which their lobbying efforts are targeted.
Many people who receive email prefer HTML over text for a number of reasons. For programmers, though, the task of creating an HTML email that will display consistently appears both simple and horribly complex. This article has described many of the issues and strategies for creating markup that will work across email software.
What’s the best idea to take away from this article? If there’s a choice to be made between a simple email design and a more complex solution, simplicity is always the safest bet.
These resources offer valuable information that will help you if you want to learn more about coding HTML email.
Email Standards Project
The Email Standards Project is probably the best starting point for understanding exactly to what degree HTML and CSS are supported by different email clients. The site also maintain an acid test that can be used to compare compliance across email software, and there are several ways in which you can participate to help improve email support of web standards.
Free HTML Email Templates from Campaign Monitor and MailChimp
Both of these email delivery services actively test their templates over time with different email clients. However, there are subtle differences in the approach that each takes — Campaign Monitor places a
style declaration within the
head tag, while MailChimp does not. Be sure to test your final HTML code with whatever email clients are used by recipients of your email list.
Plain Text Email Design Guidelines
This article lists a number of simple techniques for making text emails easier to scan.
Articles about Blocked Email Images by ClickZ and Campaign Monitor
From 2004, the ClickZ article shows how major email software compares when images are blocked or when the content is viewed in a preview pane. The Campaign Monitor article goes into greater detail, listing actual examples and ideas how to combat default image-off rendering of your emails, as well as designing your email to look okay in preview panes.
Word 2007 HTML and CSS Rendering Capabilities in Outlook 2007
The official Microsoft description of what Outlook 2007 will and will not render for HTML and CSS. Includes a link to a validator that works in Dreamweaver, as well as Microsoft editing tools.
HTML Email Tips for Web Designers
A useful, barebones list of guidelines for creating and sending email. The free email templates also are great samples to study, because the code is heavily commented and has been tested against a broad range of email software. And, finally, the Resources page includes some great links to best practices, as well as other resources.
MailChimp Email HTML Coding/Delivery Guide
Lots of great information about all aspects of HTML email, including how spam filters work.
CSS Support in HTML Emails of Hotmail, Yahoo! Mail, and Gmail by Xavier Frenette
This is excellent research that shows style-by-style results for how these three webmail services display CSS.
A Guide to CSS Support in Email
Campaign Monitor, an email service provider, has taken Xavier Frenette’s excellent work documenting CSS performance in a few email clients and expanded it to include Gmail, Hotmail, Yahoo!, and Windows Live Mail. It also covers Outlook 2003, Outlook Express, Lotus Notes, and Thunderbird on the PC, as well as Mail, Entourage, and Eudora for the Mac.
The “Secrets of HTML Email” Series
Some of this information is old but a good piece on Lotus Notes is offered.
Lotus Notes Trial Software
This page offers free downloads of the latest Lotus software, which is handy if you need to test an email with the Notes client software.
Email/Web Testing Services: BrowserCam and Litmus
These are both excellent services for testing how compatible your web pages with a variety of web browsers and operating systems. For email, Browsercam simply shows you all the warts in your HTML code, even though your email might work fine in Notes, Google Mail, and other difficult email software environments. Litmus shows how your email appears in a variety of email clients.
This decent, free online service tells you about the “spamminess” of your email. You also should look for an email delivery service that provides this sort of spam check.
CSS and Email, Kissing in a Tree
This excellent CSS-only approach to HTML email was published by A List Apart. NOTE: The author has written an update to this article, posted at the Campaign Monitor blog, Optimizing CSS presentation in HTML emails.
How HTML Code Affects E-Mail Deliverability
A decent overview that describes how different email services view the HTML you include in an HTML email. You can’t address every problem directly (for example, creating a clear boundary between the HTML and text versions of your email is a problem for your email service provider, if you use one) but it helps to know what happens.